Which Collar to Choose for Your Dog? Flat Collar or Roll Collar?
When you start getting a puppy, choosing the right collar for it is crucial. This greatly affects their comfort and safety.
There are many types of collars on the market today, including flat collars, roll collars, martingale collars, leader collars, choke chains, etc. But the two most popular collars on the market today are flat collars and roll collars.
Are you hesitating between the two right now?
After reading this article, we can help you choose the best collar for your dog
Flat Collar
Flat collar collars are made of yet another flat material and are available in a variety of material options, such as nylon, leather, and more. Comes with buckles or buttons for adjustment.
Advantage:
Suitable for Everyday Use: The flat collar is suitable for daily walking, training use and provides a secure attachment point for leashes and identification tags.
ADJUSTABLE: The flat collar has buckles for adjustment, making it perfect for growing puppies. The owner can adjust the size based on changes in the puppy’s size.
Comfort: A well-fitted collar will not make your dog feel uncomfortable, and the flat collar can be worn all day long.
Customization: Most flat collar collars come with the ability to have your dog’s identification tag attached to the collar
Durable: Flat collar collars are mostly durable, practical and have a long lifespan. And the design makes the dog comfortable and the dog will not bite the collar.
Shortcoming:
Uncontrollable: Inability to provide adequate control to larger or energetic dogs, especially if the dog tends to pull on the leash
Roll Collar
Also known as martingale or slip collars, roll collars are designed to provide gentle correction and control when walking or training your dog. Unlike flat collars, roll collars have a loop of material that tightens when tension is applied, preventing pulling behavior.
Advantage:
Easy to train: The roll collar is an effective tool for training dogs. The tightening feeling of the collar will make them better understand your instructions and behave correctly.
Shortcoming:
One of the most serious disadvantages of roll collars is that they pose some dangers to dogs.
1. Roll collar collars are not suitable for wearing all day long and without supervision. Avoid wearing it on your dog for long periods of time. Dogs may get stuck on objects, causing entanglement or risk of injury.
2. Rolled-up leather collars also risk damaging the dog’s trachea. When the dog wears the collar, it relies on the collar to distribute the pressure on the trachea. Roll-up collars are thinner and narrower than other collars and can distribute pressure. The area is small, and the pressure on the dog’s neck increases, which may lead to the risk of suffocation.
3. According to a 2006 study conducted in the Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association, “The pressure created when dogs pull on these collars can increase stress on the eyes. Therefore, dogs with glaucoma, thin corneas, and other conditions that cause eye pressure may In problematic dogs, it may worsen clinical symptoms or disease progression.”
Some Other Perspectives
After reading the above popular science, I believe you have your own judgment on what kind of dog you want to choose. In my opinion, do not use roll collars on dogs. Although it provides great help in dog training, its shortcomings are unacceptable. Putting your dog in more danger for the sake of training is unkind. In fact, as long as you train your dog carefully and patiently using professional methods, your dog can learn very well without using a collar.
There are also some claims that roll collars can prevent long-haired dogs from matting. This idea is wrong. Roll collars and flat collars actually cause just as much damage to dog hair. In order to prevent your dog’s hair from getting tangled, the correct way is to comb your dog’s hair regularly, such as combing it after every walk. Bathing your dog regularly will help clean some dirt in the hair. Don’t wear a collar for too long.
Summarize
When choosing a collar for your dog, please consider your dog’s safety and comfort. In fact, wearing the collar correctly is also necessary.
Want to buy a dog collar? Consider sevenpets, we make the most perfect dog collars and with so many options, you’re sure to find your favorite here.